PerformAction
 logo  logo  logo
  • search
    • Property Search
    • Open Houses
    • Search by Community
    • Global Search
  • callcarpenter.com
  • Buy
    • Buying a Home
    • Pay Earnest Money
  • Sell
    • Selling Your Home
    • What's My Home Worth?
  • Agents/Offices
    • Agents
    • Offices
  • Careers
    • Join Our Team
    • Our Training
  • Company
    • About Us
    • Contact Us
  • Commercial
  • Relocation
    • search
      • Property Search
      • Open Houses
      • Search by Community
      • Global Search
    • callcarpenter.com
    • Buy
      • Buying a Home
      • Pay Earnest Money
    • Sell
      • Selling Your Home
      • What's My Home Worth?
    • Agents/Offices
      • Agents
      • Offices
    • Careers
      • Join Our Team
      • Our Training
    • Company
      • About Us
      • Contact Us
    • Commercial
    • Relocation
Sign In / Sign Up
Sign In / Sign Up
Email
(800) 630-1727
Menu

1940 Nantucket Drive, Cicero, IN 46034

$750,000

  • Open House
  • New Listing
  • Price Reduced$19,000
  • Sold
  • Leased
  • Virtual Tour
-1 More Schedule
  • Property Info
  • Photo Slideshow
  • Photos
  • Print
  • Website
  • Save Listing
  • Share Listing
  • Property Info
  • Photos
  • Photo Slideshow
  • Print
  • Website
  • 5 BedroomBeds
  • 3 BathroomBaths
  • 1,606Sqft
  • 0Acres
  • Single FamilyType
  • 22075705MLS#
-1 More Schedule

Virtual Tours

  • VirtualAdditionalTourImage

Property Description

Welcome to your completely reimagined lakefront retreat at 1940 Nantucket Drive on the main body of Morse Reservoir! This stunning 5-bedroom, 3-full-bath home has been meticulously updated from top to bottom and sits on an expansive .38-acre corner lot with direct lake access and breathtaking water views. Step outside to your private boat dock featuring a canopy & electric boat lift, seawall installed (2016) has been freshly sealed, double-decker lakeside patios including lakeside fire pit, and a huge back deck with new stone wall accent-perfect for entertaining or watching sunsets over the lake. Inside, you'll find a move-in-ready masterpiece with a gorgeous updated kitchen boasting quartz countertops, stainless steel appliances, soft close cabinets, and barstool seating. Brand-new luxury vinyl plank flooring throughout, built for durability. Three completely remodeled modern bathrooms. Updated primary suite w/ high end tile shower. Fresh interior & exterior paint; updated lighting and sheik boho style light fixtures. HVAC system updated in 2022, roof in 2021, for year-round comfort. Storage shed under back deck and built in shelves in the garage. New front steps and front door. Every detail has been thoughtfully refreshed while preserving the timeless charm of this classic lake house. Located less than 20 minutes to Grand Park and just a short walk to the neighborhood park w/ new pickleball courts and a quick golf-cart ride to everything downtown Cicero has to offer-restaurants like Red Bridge Bistro, shops, and seasonal events. No HOA and plenty of room for boats, trailers, toys, or even a future pool, this rare turn-key lakefront property combines modern luxury with the laid-back lake lifestyle you've been dreaming of. Big in all the right places: lakeside entertainment space, yard size & bed/bath count to enjoy w/ friends. Investors - Amazing AirBnB opportunity w/ $100k+ projected booking revenue!


Thank you for requesting a showing of this property. A representative will be in touch with you shortly to confirm the requested showing date and time.
Please note that your appointment is not confirmed until someone contacts you.

Request Info/ Schedule Showing

Submit

Property Details 1940 Nantucket Drive, Cicero, IN 46034

Facts & Features

  • MLS #: 22075705
  • Status: Active
  • Type: Single Family
  • Sub Type: Single Family Residence
  • Year Built: 1976
  • Style: Split Level
  • Price: $750,000
  • Acres: 0.38
  • Area: 2917 - Hamilton - Jackson
  • County: Hamilton
  • Subdivision: Cicero Shores
  • Bedrooms: 5
  • Bathrooms: 3
  • Full Baths: 3
  • Total SqFt: 1,606

Amenities

  • Parking: Finished Garage, Garage Door Opener, Service Door
  • # of Garages: 2
  • View: Lake
  • Waterfront: Yes
  • Waterfront Type: Boat Slip, Dock, On Reservoir, Seawall, Water Access, Waterfront
  • Pet Friendly: Yes

Interior

  • Interior Features: Attic Access, Kitchen Island, Eat-in Kitchen, Wood Work Painted
  • Appliances: Dishwasher, Disposal, Gas Water Heater, Exhaust Fan, Microwave, Electric Oven, Refrigerator
  • Utilities: Electricity Connected, Natural Gas Connected, Sewer Connected, Water Connected
  • Heating: Natural Gas, High Efficiency (90%+ AFUE )
  • Cooling: Central Air

Exterior

  • Exterior Features: Fire Pit, Storage Shed
  • Construction: Vinyl With Stone

Schools

  • School District: Hamilton Heights School Corp
  • Elementary: Hamilton Heights Elementary School
  • Middle: Hamilton Heights Middle School
  • High: Hamilton Heights High School

Additional Information

  • Date Listed: 12/03/2025

Tax Information

  • Tax: $4,316

Output format

Property Map

 

Estimated Monthly Mortgage Calculator

This calculator is provided for informational purposes only by Burrow Services, Inc. You should not make any decisions based simply on the information provided. Values indicated are estimates and may not be accurate and are only to be used as a guide. This calculator should not be relied upon in any way as the sole source of information. Please consult your financial, tax or legal advisers for an accurate assessment of your mortgage payments and any advice relating to your personal circumstances.

Get Pre-Approved

Similar Listings

    • New Listing
    • Price Reduced$25,000
    • Open House
    • Sold
    • Leased
    • Virtual Tour
    64 Hickory Ridge Circle Cicero IN 46034
    $924,900
    3 Bed 3 Beds 3 Bath 3 Baths Sq.ft- 2,216
    MLS# 22103631 Single Family
    Listing Courtesy of Compass Indiana, LLC | andy@soldbysheets.com
    Request Info
    Delete
    Details
      • New Listing
      • Price Reduced$25,000
      • Open House
      • Sold
      • Leased
      • Virtual Tour
      23104 Sonoma Lane Cicero IN 46034
      $899,900
      4 Bed 4 Beds 6 Bath 6 Baths Sq.ft- 4,996
      MLS# 22097361 Single Family
      Listing Courtesy of Epique Inc | craig@hartwickrealty.com
      Request Info
      Delete
      Details
        • New Listing
        • Price Reduced
        • Open House
        • Sold
        • Leased
        • Virtual Tour
        11845 Deer Walk Drive Cicero IN 46034
        $869,900
        3 Bed 3 Beds 3 Bath 3 Baths Sq.ft- 4,526
        MLS# 22108987 Single Family
        Listing Courtesy of CENTURY 21 Scheetz | lstokes@c21scheetz.com
        Request Info
        Delete
        Details
          • New Listing
          • Price Reduced
          • Open House
          • Sold
          • Leased
          • Virtual Tour
          1025 Bear Cub Drive Cicero IN 46034
          $869,000
          4 Bed 4 Beds 5 Bath 5 Baths Sq.ft- 4,269
          MLS# 22107636 Single Family
          Listing Courtesy of Berkshire Hathaway Home | matt@mattsoldme.com
          Request Info
          Delete
          Details
            • New Listing
            • Price Reduced$34,900
            • Open House
            • Sold
            • Leased
            • Virtual Tour
            180 Bayshore Drive Cicero IN 46034
            $845,000
            4 Bed 4 Beds 4 Bath 4 Baths Sq.ft- 3,788
            MLS# 22085754 Single Family
            Listing Courtesy of CENTURY 21 Scheetz | lstokes@c21scheetz.com
            Request Info
            Delete
            Details
              • New Listing
              • Price Reduced
              • Open House
              • Sold
              • Leased
              • Virtual Tour
              23598 Fall Road Cicero IN 46034
              $799,000
              5 Bed 5 Beds 3 Bath 3 Baths Sq.ft- 2,568
              MLS# 22109500 Single Family
              Listing Courtesy of CENTURY 21 Scheetz | jhutcherson@c21scheetz.com
              Request Info
              Delete
              Details
                • New Listing
                • Price Reduced$10,000
                • Open House
                • Sold
                • Leased
                • Virtual Tour
                2628 Inlet Drive Cicero IN 46034
                $724,900
                3 Bed 3 Beds 2 Bath 2 Baths Sq.ft- 1,692
                MLS# 22093827 Single Family
                Listing Courtesy of Keller Williams Indy Metro NE | robsorrell@kw.com
                Request Info
                Delete
                Details
                  • New Listing
                  • Price Reduced$40,000
                  • Open House
                  • Sold
                  • Leased
                  • Virtual Tour
                  1940 Stringtown Pike Cicero IN 46034
                  $685,000
                  3 Bed 3 Beds 2 Bath 2 Baths Sq.ft- 1,536
                  MLS# 22096966 Single Family
                  Listing Courtesy of Compass Indiana, LLC | greg.cooper@compass.com
                  Request Info
                  Delete
                  Details
                    • New Listing
                    • Price Reduced
                    • Open House
                    • Sold
                    • Leased
                    • Virtual Tour
                    2360 Stringtown Pike Cicero IN 46034
                    $625,000
                    3 Bed 3 Beds 2 Bath 2 Baths Sq.ft- 1,488
                    MLS# 22112762 Single Family
                    Listing Courtesy of Compass Indiana, LLC | tammy.venable@compass.com
                    Request Info
                    Delete
                    Details
                      • New Listing
                      • Price Reduced$39,100
                      • Open House
                      • Sold
                      • Leased
                      • Virtual Tour
                      4000 W Morse Drive Cicero IN 46034
                      $599,900
                      5 Bed 5 Beds 4 Bath 4 Baths Sq.ft- 4,621
                      MLS# 22100859 Single Family
                      Listing Courtesy of Compass Indiana, LLC | andy@soldbysheets.com
                      Request Info
                      Delete
                      Details
                        • New Listing
                        • Price Reduced
                        • Open House
                        • Sold
                        • Leased
                        • Virtual Tour
                        3050 W Morse Drive Cicero IN 46034
                        $585,000
                        4 Bed 4 Beds 4 Bath 4 Baths Sq.ft- 3,920
                        MLS# 22108274 Single Family
                        Listing Courtesy of F.C. Tucker Company | aaron.galvin@talktotucker.com
                        Request Info
                        Delete
                        Details
                          • New Listing
                          • Price Reduced$70,000
                          • Open House
                          • Sold
                          • Leased
                          • Virtual Tour
                          8275 E 216th Street Cicero IN 46034
                          $580,000
                          0 Bed 0 Beds 0 Bath 0 Baths Sq.ft- 1,564
                          MLS# 22106115 Single Family
                          Listing Courtesy of Office F.C. Tucker Company
                          Request Info
                          Delete
                          Details
                           Carpenter Realtors Logo
                          (800) 630-1727

                          Address

                          Carpenter Realtors, Inc. 8901 S. Meridian St. Indianapolis IN 46217

                          Contact us

                          (800) 630-1727 eclientcare@callcarpenter.com

                          Connect

                          Quick Links

                          Privacy Policy Terms Of Use DMCA Notice Accessibility
                          Agent Login
                          Copyright © 2026 Carpenter Realtors, Inc.
                          • Comparison List   0

                          Carpenter Realtors is powered by Burrow Services, Inc.