PerformAction
 logo  logo  logo
  • search
    • Property Search
    • Open Houses
    • Search by Community
    • Global Search
  • Buy
    • Buying a Home
    • Pay Earnest Money
  • Sell
    • Selling Your Home
    • What's My Home Worth?
  • Agents/Offices
    • Agents
    • Offices
  • Careers
    • Join Our Team
    • Our Training
  • Company
    • About Us
    • Contact Us
  • Commercial
  • Relocation
    • search
      • Property Search
      • Open Houses
      • Search by Community
      • Global Search
    • Buy
      • Buying a Home
      • Pay Earnest Money
    • Sell
      • Selling Your Home
      • What's My Home Worth?
    • Agents/Offices
      • Agents
      • Offices
    • Careers
      • Join Our Team
      • Our Training
    • Company
      • About Us
      • Contact Us
    • Commercial
    • Relocation
Sign In / Sign Up
Sign In / Sign Up
Email
(800) 630-1727
Menu

37-41 Public Square, Shelbyville, IN 46176

$1,500,000

  • Open House
  • New Listing
  • Coming Soon
  • Price Reduced
  • Sold
  • Leased
  • Virtual Tour
-1 More Schedule
  • Property Info
  • Listing Agent
  • Photo Slideshow
  • Photos
  • Print
  • Website
  • Save Listing
  • Share Listing
  • Property Info
  • Listing Agent
  • Photos
  • Photo Slideshow
  • Print
  • Website
  • 0 BedroomBeds
  • 0 BathroomBaths
  • 17,490Sqft
  • 0Acres
  • Commercial SaleType
  • ActiveStatus
  • 22134983MLS#
-1 More Schedule

Virtual Tours

  • VirtualTourImage
  • VirtualAdditionalTourImage

Property Description

37-41 Public Square is a +/-17,420 SF historic mixed-use investment on Shelbyville's Public Square, offered at a projected 10% cap rate at full occupancy and stabilization. The property combines three income streams: #37 - a ground-floor retail or office space, #39 - a bistro space of approximately +/-6,100 SF with a lower level of similar size, and #41- 6 upper-level apartments being renovated during marketing period and ready for occupancy soon. The bistro features a nice sized bar area separate from the main dining room, with its own entrance on Jackson Street, and potential for outdoor seating within the DORA zone. It is well suited for a restaurant, brewpub, or entertainment concept. The apartments (one 3BR, two 2BR, two 1BR and 1 Studio) are being updated with new appliances, cabinetry, countertops, flooring, fixtures, and paint, with projected rents up to $1700 per month. The seller is actively leasing the commercial and residential spaces during the marketing period. Located in Shelbyville's historic district and DORA zone, the property is steps from the square's festivals and community events, with plenty of free street parking, free public parking in the garage directly across the street and a paved lot for tenant parking on Jackson St. A planned data center project nearby is expected to bring increased activity to the area. See Broker Bay for showing instructions.


Claudia Heidelberger

Listing Agent

Claudia Heidelberger

  • (317) 391-6329
Email Me
Email Me

Thank you for requesting a showing of this property. A representative will be in touch with you shortly to confirm the requested showing date and time.
Please note that your appointment is not confirmed until someone contacts you.

Request Info/ Schedule Showing

Submit

Property Details 37-41 Public Square, Shelbyville, IN 46176

Facts & Features

  • MLS #: 22134983
  • Status: Active
  • Type: Commercial Sale
  • Sub Type: Mixed Use
  • Year Built: 1900
  • Price: $1,500,000
  • Acres: 0.13
  • Area: 7308 - Shelby - Addison
  • County: Shelby
  • Total SqFt: 17,490

Amenities

  • Pet Friendly: Yes

Interior

  • Utilities: Cable Available, Electricity Connected, Natural Gas Available

Schools

  • School District: Shelbyville Central Schools
  • Middle: Shelbyville Middle School

Additional Information

  • Date Listed: 11/06/2026
  • Zoning: COMMERCIAL

Tax Information

  • Tax: $12,622

Output format

Property Map

 

Estimated Monthly Mortgage Calculator

This calculator is provided for informational purposes only by Burrow Services, Inc. You should not make any decisions based simply on the information provided. Values indicated are estimates and may not be accurate and are only to be used as a guide. This calculator should not be relied upon in any way as the sole source of information. Please consult your financial, tax or legal advisers for an accurate assessment of your mortgage payments and any advice relating to your personal circumstances.

Get Pre-Approved
 Carpenter Realtors Logo
(800) 630-1727

Address

Carpenter Realtors, Inc. 8901 S. Meridian St. Indianapolis IN 46217

Contact us

(800) 630-1727 eclientcare@callcarpenter.com

Connect

Quick Links

Privacy Policy Terms Of Use DMCA Notice Accessibility
 Carpenter Realtors Logo
Agent Login

Copyright © 2026 Carpenter Realtors, Inc. All rights reserved.

Indiana Broker of Record License# CO88700191.
Equal Housing Opportunity.

  • Comparison List   0

Carpenter Realtors is powered by Burrow Services, Inc.